|part of:||Uncut: The 100 Greatest Debut Albums (2006) (number: 65) (order: 65)|
The Guardian 100 Best Albums Ever (number: 93) (order: 93)
CritiqueBrainz ReviewsThere are 2 reviews on CritiqueBrainz. You can also write your own.
The first of the three disparate Dexys masterpieces and one of the greatest UK debuts ever, this was - with hindsight - the bridge between punk and new romanticism. Upon its 1980 release it just sounded weird: brazen yet beautiful, both lovingly retro and caustically original. Kevin Rowland had growled in Midlands punk bands but now felt an epiphany. Soul, he decided, was the best way to channel dissent and desire. He recruited musicians who could actually play - and play horns - and layered lyrics over shapes mapped out by Stax and Motown.
The pulsating result opened up new rooms in the house of groove, yet it's Rowland's persona which dominates. His stressed, committed vocals and tumbling torrents of words remind one how rarely we hear visionary auteurs in pop. Even in 2010, moments here scrape the dust from your ears. (A second disc offers numerous radio sessions and demos.) It just so happens that it's the least brilliant of the hallowed Dexys triptych, yet Too-Rye-Ay and Don't Stand Me Down reached giddying zeniths.
Rife with "you-talkin'-to-me?" attitude, its chart hits were staccato stomp Geno and the (superior) There, There My Dear, in which Rowland rants at an "anti-fashion" phoney who affects to like Sinatra. (Like many Rowland-isms, this was misunderstood - he loves Sinatra.) Burn It Down (nee Dance Stance) opens with a radio playing snippets of dinosaur rock, punk and even The Specials before it's flicked off and the horn trio urge you to "welcome the new soul vision". Rowland is in his element railing against perceived sleights: his causes include the Irish, literature and a hunger for R-E-S-P-E-C-T. While the octet's instrumentals and covers are sharp, the slower, introspective, narcissistic numbers are the bigger clue that here was a major voice. In I'm Just Looking and I Couldn't Help It If I Tried, Rowland becomes a white existential Otis, chiefly by sheer willpower and self-belief.
Doubt was to disturb him, as it does all great artists. This though was the sound of a soul released from a straitjacket. While his then Two Tone rivals will always read as prose, this still blazes as poetry.